When someone has experienced a medical emergency and is taken to a hospital, the first thing medical professionals do is assess and stabilize–halt the damage. The next steps include determining the need for any long-term treatments needed to get that person back on track for an independent, healthy and happy life. That’s how medical needs are met. Why isn’t that how we handle financial needs?
The hospital does not assume that the correct thing to do is to keep the patient in the facility, dependent upon the staff and equipment in place there. Hospitals are expensive and are designed for aggressive, short-term care–not long-term–care. If necessary, the patient is referred out to less expensive, longer-term care facilities. The ultimate goal is to have the patient be able to live on their own, without any kind of medical support provided by others. This not only allows resources to be used by the next person, but it gives patients the freedom, dignity and joy that comes with unassisted living.
This is not how our society is trending when it comes to other areas where people may be hurting. For example, when people are suffering financially, the increasing tendency is not only to give assistance, but to give ever-increasing aid over extended periods of time. There is little, if any, thought given to stabilizing the financial situation–halting the damage–and helping that person to return financial independence.
When we create long-term dependencies in order to address short-term solutions, we are not creating a compassionate solution: We are handing down a life sentence. Perhaps for generations.
Why is there a difference between how we as a society handle people with medical issues and people with financial challenges?
The answer is in two parts: 1. The motivation of the person with the financial need and 2. The motivation of the mechanism that provides the financial relief.
Let’s take the individual’s motivation. No one wants to stay in a hospital. Bad food, terrible beds, and constant poking and prodding and other interruptions. And no Netflix. But some people might very well want to stay in a financial “hospital”; live easy and live at home. On direct deposit or EBT. Be aware that some people will say they can’t succeed on their own, when they really mean they simply won’t or don’t want to. (Can’t vs. Won’t) What about the motivations of the workers administering the various financial assistance programs? The more money they give out, and the more people they give it to, the better their job security and chances for promotion. The requirements for jobs like these are not high; show up, be polite, fill out forms–repeat. Unless protected by strong unions or regulations–or both–competition for jobs like can be intense. The incentive is to give out more money to more people for longer periods of time. That’s deceptively easy to do, because there are no apparent limits the financial aid workers can see to limit the amount of money available to be handed out.
The same it not true about the medical world. It takes many more years to become a nurse, doctor, or surgeon than it does to work in a government-run, financial assistance office. The medical people know that their services will always be highly valued and their jobs secure for as long as they want them without having to keep patients dependent longer than necessary. And the resources in the medical world are obviously limited; insurance companies are not willing to pay for any extras, and the beds, operating rooms, analytical equipment and medical staff are often in short supply.
Let’s all learn from the medical community. When helping, stabilize the person you are assisting–halt the damage. Then find a long-term solution that will give them the best chance to make it on their own, all while giving encouragement. Remember, continuing to help after someone could help themselves is not a life solution. It is life sentence.
Will Luden, writing from my home office at 7,200’ in Colorado Springs
Latest posts by Will Luden (see all)
- Which “New Normal?” Crises reveal character, not build it. (EP.218) - March 31, 2020
- Are We a Team of Rivals, or Rivals to The Bitter End? (EP.217) - March 27, 2020
- Competing for Toilet Paper and Racism (EP. 216) - March 24, 2020